Anti-Terrorism Court granted post-arrest bail to PTI Punjab President Dr. Yasmin Rashid in the PTI Mughalpura case

The May 9, 2023 riots remain highly controversial as one of the most politically surcharged episodes in recent Pakistan history, continuing to send ripples across the judicial landscape. On Saturday, this case again snatched headlines after the Anti-Terrorism Court granted post-arrest bail to PTI Punjab President Dr. Yasmin Rashid in the PTI Mughalpura case, regarding the alleged burning of police vehicles.

Having spent months behind bars, Dr. Rashid’s case had become synonymous with the general saga of PTI leadership embroiled in numerous cases filed in the aftermath of the May 9 mayhem. The most recent ruling brings a sudden change of fortunes for the defense.

A Dramatic Hearing Behind Prison Walls

The hearing was anything but ordinary. Because of security and administrative reasons, ATC-I Judge Manzer Ali Gill held the proceedings inside Kot Lakhpat Jail, where Dr. Rashid is currently imprisoned.

The setting of the courtroom amidst prison walls added tension and solemnity to an already sensitive case. The judge listened to both sides before announcing the much-awaited verdict by many political observers.

Defense Argues Consistency and Fairness

Representing Dr. Rashid, Barrister Taimur Malik argued based on a single principle: the rule of consistency. He drew the court’s attention to earlier decisions where bail had already been granted to several key PTI leaders in similar or linked cases. These included:

• PTI founder Imran Khan
• Former senator Ejaz Chaudhry
• Former Punjab governor Umar Sarfraz Cheema

The defense contended that since senior members of the party, who faced similar accusations, had been granted bail, withholding it from Dr. Rashid would amount to a denial of judicial precedent. Malik asserted that the prosecution had not presented any hard evidence that placed Dr. Rashid at the scene of the crime in Mughalpura.

Court’s Verdict: A Measured Relief

After a consideration of the submissions, post-arrest bail was granted by the ATC, giving a much-needed legal reprieve to Dr. Rashid. Though the case itself is still intact, the bail is an important turning point both for her and for PTI’s legal landscape following the 2023 unrest.

The ruling is a part of a broader pattern emerging across similar May 9 cases in courts, which have begun to emphasize due process and consistent legal treatment over political pressures.

Political Implications and Public Reaction

Dr. Yasmin Rashid, an outspoken politician with a long history of political engagement, has been at the centre of attention for some time now. Social media was full of PTI supporters celebrating the decision as one that comes at the bleak moment faced by the party.

However, political analysts view the development in the context of a broader trend unfolding. With many PTI leaders getting bail in May 9 cases continuously, serious questions have emerged about the strength of evidence, lapses in investigation, and where the long-term trajectory of the cases is headed.

The ruling also puts pressure on investigators and prosecutors to firm up their case, with increasing numbers of defendants challenging the bases of their charges.

A Case Far From Over

While bail does bring temporary reprieve, the case of the PTI Mughalpura case is far from over. The prosecution may revisit evidence, pursue new angles, or call additional witnesses. Meanwhile, Dr. Rashid and her legal team prepare for the next phase, optimistic yet cautious.

With the polity in Pakistan remaining tense and polarized, each courtroom development adds another layer to an evolving national narrative.

Follow Pakistan Updates for more news and updates.